Acid-Base Disorders
Contents (8)
Acid-base disorders represent derangements in the body's pH balance, classified as metabolic (HCO3− changes) or respiratory (CO2 changes) in origin. These disorders are among the most frequently tested topics on the USMLE because they integrate physiology, biochemistry, and clinical medicine while appearing in virtually every organ system. Proper identification and treatment of acid-base disturbances is essential for managing critically ill patients, as severe pH derangements (typically pH <7.15 or >7.55) can cause cardiovascular collapse, arrhythmias, and altered mental status.
High anion gap metabolic acidosis — excess acid production or retention
- Increased organic acid generation: diabetic, alcoholic, and starvation ketoacidosis (insulinopenia/glucagon excess drives ketogenesis); type A lactic acidosis from hypoperfusion (shock, mesenteric ischemia, seizure); type B lactic acidosis without hypoxia (metformin accumulation, linezolid, propofol infusion syndrome, thiamine deficiency, malignancy)
- Toxic ingestions: methanol → formic acid; ethylene glycol → glycolic/oxalic acid; propylene glycol (IV lorazepam diluent); salicylates produce a mixed picture
- Failure of acid excretion: uremia in advanced CKD, where sulfate and phosphate anions accumulate
Normal anion gap (hyperchloremic) acidosis — bicarbonate loss or impaired H+ handling
- GI bicarbonate loss: diarrhea, pancreatic or biliary fistula, ureteral diversion
- Renal loss/dysfunction: proximal (type 2) and distal (type 1) RTA, type 4 RTA from hypoaldosteronism, carbonic anhydrase inhibitors, large-volume normal saline resuscitation
Metabolic alkalosis
- Chloride-responsive: vomiting, nasogastric suction, loop/thiazide diuretics, post-hypercapnic state
- Chloride-resistant: primary hyperaldosteronism, Cushing syndrome, licorice, Bartter and Gitelman syndromes, severe hypokalemia
Respiratory disorders by mechanism
- Acidosis: depressed drive (opioids, benzodiazepines, obesity hypoventilation, brainstem lesion), neuromuscular failure (Guillain–Barré, myasthenic crisis, ALS), obstructive disease (COPD, status asthmaticus), chest wall restriction (kyphoscoliosis, flail chest)
- Alkalosis: hypoxemic drive (pulmonary embolism, pneumonia, altitude), direct medullary stimulation (sepsis, pain/anxiety, salicylates, progesterone in pregnancy, hepatic encephalopathy), iatrogenic overventilation
Risk factors examiners plant
- Modifiable: alcohol use disorder, opioid/sedative use, diuretic misuse or bulimia, metformin continued during AKI or contrast exposure, smoking (COPD), obesity, poorly controlled diabetes — the ADA Standards of Care flag insulin omission and intercurrent illness as the dominant DKA precipitants
- Non-modifiable: CKD (KDIGO notes metabolic acidosis emerges as GFR falls), inherited tubulopathies, older age with reduced renal reserve, pregnancy (a physiologic chronic respiratory alkalosis, not pathology)
The body maintains pH between 7.35–7.45 through three primary mechanisms:
Buffer Systems
- Bicarbonate buffer system (HCO3−/H2CO3) is the most important extracellular buffer; carbonic acid (H2CO3) rapidly equilibrates with CO2 and H2O via the reaction: CO2 + H2O ↔ H2CO3 ↔ H+ + HCO3−
- Phosphate buffer (HPO4²−/H2PO4−) and protein buffers (including hemoglobin) provide additional buffering capacity
- Buffers work within seconds but cannot eliminate acid/base loads
Respiratory Compensation
- The respiratory system eliminates volatile acid (CO2) through increased or decreased minute ventilation
- Medullary chemoreceptors sense changes in PaCO2 and pH to trigger appropriate ventilatory responses
- Respiratory compensation occurs within minutes to hours and can correct pH but not return HCO3− to normal
Renal Compensation
- The kidneys regulate HCO3− reabsorption (proximal tubule) and H+ secretion (collecting duct)
- Renal compensation occurs over hours to days and is the most powerful long-term mechanism
- The kidney can return HCO3− toward normal and restore acid-base status
Primary Disorders and Compensation
- Metabolic acidosis → respiratory compensation (↓ PaCO2 via hyperventilation)
- Metabolic alkalosis → respiratory compensation (↑ PaCO2 via hypoventilation)
- Respiratory acidosis → renal compensation (↑ HCO3− reabsorption)
- Respiratory alkalosis → renal compensation (↓ HCO3− reabsorption)
Metabolic Acidosis
- Kussmaul respirations (deep, labored breathing) – classically seen in diabetic ketoacidosis; occurs when pH <7.1–7.2
- Fatigue, malaise, and generalized weakness
- Nausea, vomiting, and anorexia; abdominal pain if severe
- Altered mental status, confusion, or lethargy in severe cases (pH <7.15)
- Cardiovascular instability: hypotension, decreased cardiac contractility, arrhythmias
Metabolic Alkalosis
- Hypokalemia symptoms: muscle weakness, cramping, fatigue
- Tetany, paresthesias (due to hypocalcemia from decreased ionized calcium at higher pH)
- Altered mental status, confusion, or irritability
- Cardiac arrhythmias (especially with concurrent hypokalemia)
- Hypoventilation may be present as respiratory compensation but is often blunted
Respiratory Acidosis
- Headache and flushed appearance (from CO2 vasodilation)
- Dyspnea, tachypnea, or use of accessory muscles (if acute and compensatory)
- Altered mental status: confusion, drowsiness, obtundation ("CO2 narcosis") when severe
- Papilledema may be present due to cerebral vasodilation
- Tremor ("asterixis")
Respiratory Alkalosis
- Lightheadedness, dizziness
- Paresthesias (perioral and in extremities) and tetany from hypocalcemia
- Anxiety, palpitations, sense of impending doom
- Syncope in severe cases
- Often asymptomatic if mild
Clinical Pearl: The symptoms of acid-base disorders often overlap with symptoms of the underlying disease (e.g., dyspnea in a patient with pneumonia causing respiratory acidosis), making clinical judgment essential.
Arterial Blood Gas (ABG) Analysis – The Foundation
- Obtain ABG (not venous) for accurate assessment of oxygenation and acid-base status
- Record: pH, PaCO2, HCO3−, PaO2, SaO2
- Use a systematic approach to interpretation:
Step 1: Identify the Primary Disorder
- Determine if pH is low (acidemia) or high (alkalemia)
- Identify which parameter (PaCO2 or HCO3−) is abnormal in the same direction as pH:
- Low pH + low HCO3− = metabolic acidosis (primary)
- Low pH + high PaCO2 = respiratory acidosis (primary)
- High pH + high HCO3− = metabolic alkalosis (primary)
- High pH + low PaCO2 = respiratory alkalosis (primary)
Step 2: Assess Appropriateness of Compensation
- Use predicted compensation formulas to determine if respiratory/renal response is appropriate:
For Metabolic Acidosis (Winter's Formula)
- Expected PaCO2 = 1.5 × [HCO3−] + (±2)
- If actual PaCO2 is higher than expected → concurrent respiratory acidosis is present
- If actual PaCO2 is lower than expected → concurrent respiratory alkalosis is present
For Metabolic Alkalosis
- Expected PaCO2 = 40 + 0.6 × ([HCO3−] − 24) (±2)
- Most metabolic alkalosis patients cannot hyperventilate sufficiently, so respiratory compensation is often inadequate
For Respiratory Acidosis (Acute vs. Chronic)
- Acute: HCO3− increases by 1 mEq/L for every 10 mmHg increase in PaCO2
- Chronic: HCO3− increases by 3–4 mEq/L for every 10 mmHg increase in PaCO2
- Helps distinguish acute vs. chronic lung disease
For Respiratory Alkalosis
- Acute: HCO3− decreases by 2 mEq/L for every 10 mmHg decrease in PaCO2
- Chronic: HCO3− decreases by 3–5 mEq/L for every 10 mmHg decrease in PaCO2
Step 3: Calculate Anion Gap (if metabolic acidosis)
- Anion Gap (AG) = [Na+] − ([Cl−] + [HCO3−])
- Normal AG = 8–12 mEq/L (varies by lab; some labs use 10–14)
- High AG metabolic acidosis (AG >12) suggests addition of unmeasured anions (organic acids)
- Mnemonics: MUDPILES (Methanol, Uremia, Diabetic ketoacidosis, Propylene glycol, Isoniazid, Lactic acid, Ethylene glycol, Salicylates)
- Normal AG metabolic acidosis (AG 8–12) suggests HCO3− loss or H+ retention without organic acid accumulation
- Causes: diarrhea (HCO3− loss), renal tubular acidosis (H+ retention), ureterosigmoidostomy
Step 4: Delta Gap (if high AG metabolic acidosis)
- ΔAG = Actual AG − Normal AG (assume 12)
- Compare ΔAG to decrease in HCO3− (24 − actual HCO3−):
- ΔAG = ΔHCO3− → isolated high AG metabolic acidosis
- ΔAG > ΔHCO3− → concurrent metabolic alkalosis
- ΔAG < ΔHCO3− →
Immediate stabilisation
- Airway, breathing, circulation first: severe acidemia blunts myocardial contractility and causes catecholamine resistance; if the patient is in arrest, follow AHA ACLS — defibrillate ventricular fibrillation / pulseless VT and treat the acidosis by restoring perfusion, not by pushing bicarbonate reflexively
- Treat the cause, not the number: fluid resuscitation and source control for lactic acidosis (Surviving Sepsis Campaign), naloxone for opioid-induced hypercapnia, ventilation for neuromuscular failure
Disorder-specific first-line therapy
- DKA: isotonic crystalloid, IV regular insulin infusion, and potassium repletion — per the ADA Standards of Care, hold insulin until K+ exceeds ~3.3 mEq/L, and reserve sodium bicarbonate for pH <6.9
- Toxic alcohols: alcohol dehydrogenase inhibitor — fomepizole — is preferred over ethanol, with cofactors (folate for methanol; thiamine and pyridoxine for ethylene glycol) and urgent hemodialysis for end-organ toxicity or severe acidemia, per American Academy of Clinical Toxicology guidance
- Salicylate toxicity: alkali therapy — sodium bicarbonate infusion with aggressive potassium repletion — to alkalinize serum and urine and trap salicylate; hemodialysis for altered mental status, pulmonary edema, or renal failure, consistent with EXTRIP workgroup recommendations
- Chronic metabolic acidosis of CKD: oral alkali — sodium bicarbonate tablets — when serum bicarbonate is persistently low, per KDIGO
- Chloride-responsive metabolic alkalosis (urine Cl− low): isotonic saline plus KCl; chloride-resistant (urine Cl− high): treat the mineralocorticoid excess, e.g. an MRA such as spironolactone
- Respiratory acidosis in COPD exacerbation: noninvasive positive-pressure ventilation is first-line per GOLD, with titrated oxygen to an SpO2 of roughly 88–92%
Escalation and definitive care
- Renal replacement therapy for refractory acidemia with AKI, dialyzable toxin, or volume overload
- Acetazolamide for diuretic-associated alkalosis with volume overload; HCl infusion via central line is a last resort
Contraindicated or discouraged
- Routine bicarbonate in lactic acidosis with pH above roughly 7.15 (Surviving Sepsis Campaign suggests against it)
- Paper-bag rebreathing for hyperventilation — risks hypoxemia and masks pulmonary embolism
- Abrupt normalization of PaCO2 in chronic hypercapnia (post-hypercapnic alkalosis, seizures)
Complications of severe acidemia
- Cardiovascular collapse (emergency): H+ impairs myofilament calcium responsiveness and downregulates adrenergic receptors → depressed contractility, arteriolar vasodilation, and vasopressor-refractory hypotension; signalled by rising lactate despite adequate pressors
- Arrhythmia and hyperkalemia (emergency): mineral (non-gap) acidoses drive K+ out of cells more than organic acidoses; peaked T waves or a widening QRS is the tell
- CNS depression: obtundation and coma; in chronic respiratory acidosis, asterixis and papilledema from cerebral vasodilation
- Chronic acidosis of CKD: buffering by bone releases calcium and phosphate → demineralization, plus muscle catabolism and accelerated GFR decline — the rationale KDIGO gives for alkali therapy
Complications of alkalemia
- Tetany and seizures: alkalosis increases albumin binding of calcium → falling ionized calcium; Chvostek and Trousseau signs appear with perioral paresthesias
- Reduced tissue oxygen delivery: leftward shift of the oxyhemoglobin dissociation curve plus cerebral vasoconstriction → syncope, and in the ventilated patient, hypocapnia-induced cerebral ischemia
- Hypokalemia with arrhythmia: transcellular K+ shift compounds renal losses
Complications of therapy
- Sodium bicarbonate: generated CO2 crosses the blood–brain barrier faster than HCO3− → paradoxical intracellular/CSF acidosis; also hypernatremia, volume overload, worsened hypokalemia, and ionized hypocalcemia causing tetany
- DKA treatment: cerebral edema (emergency, chiefly in children) from rapid osmolar shifts — a declining sensorium or bradycardia with hypertension after initial improvement; also insulin-driven hypokalemia and hypoglycemia, and a hyperchloremic non-gap acidosis from large-volume saline
- Over-rapid ventilatory correction of chronic hypercapnia: retained renal bicarbonate is unmasked → post-hypercapnic metabolic alkalosis with seizures
- Intubating a salicylate-poisoned patient: loss of compensatory hyperventilation collapses the pH and can precipitate death — a recognized peri-intubation catastrophe
- Ethylene glycol: calcium oxalate crystal deposition → AKI; methanol: optic neuropathy and permanent blindness
- A normal pH does not exclude disease: a normal pH with a widened anion gap, or with wildly abnormal PaCO2 and HCO3−, means a mixed disorder. Always calculate the gap even when pH looks fine.
- Salicylate poisoning is the classic mixed picture: primary respiratory alkalosis (direct medullary stimulation) plus high anion gap metabolic acidosis. Tinnitus, tachypnea, and fever in an adult with a normal-ish pH is the stem. Best next step is a salicylate level plus sodium bicarbonate for serum and urinary alkalinization; do not intubate casually.
- Osmolar gap plus anion gap acidosis = toxic alcohol. Oxalate crystals and AKI point to ethylene glycol; visual blurring or snowfield vision points to methanol. Single best next step is fomepizole, then dialysis.
- Urine anion gap sorts a normal-gap acidosis: negative (neGUTive) means intact renal NH4+ excretion and a GI cause such as diarrhea; positive means renal tubular acidosis. Type 1 gives urine pH >5.5 with hypokalemia and calcium phosphate stones; type 4 is the hyperkalemic one, classically diabetic nephropathy.
- Vomiting or NG suction produces hypochloremic, hypokalemic metabolic alkalosis with paradoxical aciduria; urine chloride is low and the patient is saline-responsive. High urine chloride redirects you to hyperaldosteronism, Bartter, or Gitelman.
- Winter's formula is the single most tested calculation: if measured PaCO2 exceeds predicted, a superimposed respiratory acidosis has been missed — a frequent reason an intubated patient decompensates.
- Common distractor — bicarbonate for DKA. The ADA Standards of Care reserve it for pH below 6.9; the answer in most DKA stems is fluids, insulin infusion, and potassium, with insulin withheld until K+ is repleted.
- Second common distractor — treating the number in lactic acidosis. The Surviving Sepsis Campaign directs you to perfusion and source control, not alkali, at moderate pH values.